ЄВРОПЕЙСЬКІ СТАНДАРТИ АДВОКАТСЬКОЇ ДІЯЛЬНОСТІ

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.71404/EP.2026.2-2.55

Keywords:

european standards, advocacy, attorney’s labor activity, socio-labor guarantees, attorney-client privilege, independence clause, law firm, employed attorney, dual employment, unified social contribution

Abstract

The scientific article provides a comprehensive theoretical and legal analysis of the implementation of European standards of advocacy into the legal system of Ukraine. Particular attention is devoted to an aspect scarcely explored in national doctrine - the legal regulation ofan attorney’s employment activities, their socio-labor rights, and professional guarantees in the course of performing official duties. It is substantiated that the modern European model ofjustice requires a departure from the archaic perception of an attorney solely as a “free agent” and demands a clear regulation of their status within labor relations. Within the scope of the study, the genesis of European deontological guidelines is analyzed in detail, spanning from the 1977 Perugia Declaration and the CCBE Code of Conduct for European Lawyers to the Charter of Core Principles of the European Legal Profession and specific EU Directives. The author examines the advanced experience of the European Union countries, particularly France (with its institutes of “collaborateur liberal” and “avocat salarié”) and Germany (regulation ofthe “Syndikusrechtsanwalt” status in the BRAO), where the dichotomy between the strict labor subordination of an employee and their professional independence as a human rights defender has been successfully resolved. Through the prism of comparative analysis, significant conflicts in national legislation are identified, notably the inconsistency among the provisions of the Tax Code of Ukraine, the Labor Code of Ukraine, and the Law of Ukraine “On Advocacy and Legal Practice”. The systemic risks for businesses are analyzed in cases where attorneys are hired as in-house counsels without the proper execution of a core agreement on the provision of legal aid, which leads to the loss of attorney-client privileges and the inability to recover court costs. Special attention is paid to the evolution ofjudicial practice, particularly the landmark rulings of the Cassation Administrative Court within the Supreme Court regarding the impermissibility of double payment of the unified social contribution (USC) by attorneys employed under labor contracts. Based on the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union (specifically, the precedent-setting Akzo Nobel case), the study proves the impermissibility of automatically extending legal professional privilege (LPP) to corporate in-house lawyers who are not subject to the disciplinary control of bar associations. Following the results of the research, concrete proposals for reforming Ukrainian legislation are formulated. The necessity of legislative recognition of new organizational forms of legal practice (employment within a law firm or bureau) and the mandatory implementation of a so-called “independence clause” into labor contracts is substantiated. This clause is designed to protect the right of an employed attorney to refuse to follow an employer’s instructions if they contradict the professional oath, ethical standards, or the client’s best interests, without the threat of disciplinary dismissal.

Author Biography

  • Дмитро Григорович Ганга

    аспірант кафедри трудового права, Національний юридичний університет імені Ярослава Мудрого, м. Харків

Published

2026-05-29

How to Cite

Ганга, Д. Г. (2026). ЄВРОПЕЙСЬКІ СТАНДАРТИ АДВОКАТСЬКОЇ ДІЯЛЬНОСТІ. Європейські перспективи, 2-2, 417-423. https://doi.org/10.71404/EP.2026.2-2.55