МЕЖІ ВТРУЧАННЯ У ПРИВАТНІСТЬ ПІД ЧАС ПРОВЕДЕННЯ НЕГЛАСНИХ СЛІДЧИХ (РОЗШУКОВИХ) ДІЙ

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.71404/EP.2026.2-2.81

Keywords:

covert investigative (surveillance) activities, limits on interference with privacy, right to privacy, judicial oversight, investigating judge, court, private communications, criminal proceedings, protection of constitutional rights and freedoms

Abstract

The conduct of covert investigative (search) actions involves a significant intrusion into an individual’s private life, carried out secretly and without the individual having the opportunity to directly defend their rights at the time such actions are being conducted. Under these circumstances, it is particularly important to clearly define the permissible limits of such intrusion and to specify them in the investigating judge’s ruling. This article examines the content and main components of the limits on interference with privacy during covert investigative (search) operations and determines their significance for the exercise of preliminary and subsequent judicial oversight. The purpose of the study is to define the content and structure of the limits on interference with privacy during covert investigative (surveillance) operations, to clarify their role in the mechanism of judicial oversight, and to formulate approaches for determining the permissible scope of such interference in the investigatingjudge’s ruling. In the course of this study, the formal-legal method was used to analyze the provisions of the Constitution of Ukraine, the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine, and international legal standards for the protection of privacy; the systemic-structural method was used to determine the interrelationship among the individual components of the limits on interference; the logical-legal method—to formulate the author’s propositions and conclusions; and the method of analyzing judicial practice—to clarify the approaches of the European Court of Human Rights and the Supreme Court to assessing the legality and justification of covert interference in an individual’s private sphere. Particular attention is paid to the need to establish a connection between the specific individual or object subject to non-cooperative surveillance, the scope of information that may be obtained, technical identifiers, the duration of the intrusion, and the procedural purpose of its implementation. The paper proposes the use of the category personal-functional specification of the limits of interference which reflects the need to tailor judicial authorization to the individual case and the inadmissibility of a broad interpretation of its content. Based on the results of the study, it was concluded that the limits of interference with privacy should be considered as an independent element of the mechanism of judicial oversight over the conduct of special investigative measures. The ruling of the investigating judge must serve not only an authorizing function but also a restrictive one, clearly defining the permissible scope of interference with an individual’s private sphere. It has been established that specifying such limits is important not only at the stage of deciding whether to grant authorization for the conduct of special investigative measures, but also during the subsequent review of the legality of the interference actually carried out and the evaluation of the results obtained. Promising areas for further research include the legal consequences of exceeding the scope of judicial authorization, the criteria for the proportionality of interference, and the specifics of determining the permissible limits of special investigative measures in the digital environment. In the course of scientific discussion, it has been substantiated that the limits of interference with privacy cannot be reduced solely to the type of special investigative measure or the duration of the investigating judge’s ruling. It is proposed that their structure include personal, subject-and-information-based, technical-identification, temporal, and functional aspects.

Author Biography

  • Раїса Володимирівна Перелигіна

    кандидат юридичних наук, доцент, доцент кафедри кримінального права та процесу Київський університет права НАН України

Published

2026-05-29

How to Cite

Перелигіна, Р. В. (2026). МЕЖІ ВТРУЧАННЯ У ПРИВАТНІСТЬ ПІД ЧАС ПРОВЕДЕННЯ НЕГЛАСНИХ СЛІДЧИХ (РОЗШУКОВИХ) ДІЙ. Європейські перспективи, 2-2, 635-641. https://doi.org/10.71404/EP.2026.2-2.81